Categories
Digital Movies & TV Movies & Television (Videos) Online Videos TV Episodes & Movies TV Series TV Series (Specific Episodes)

MY TWO DADS: PILOT (Season 1: Episode 1)

SUMMARY:                   RUNNING TIME: 24:00 Min.

Premiering on NBC-TV on September 20, 1987, the pilot episode for “My Two Dads” was scripted by series producer-creator Michael Jacobs and directed by John Tracy.  Thirteen years after a Key West getaway from college and their friendship broken up over their rivalry for beautiful Marcy Bradford, high-strung, yuppie financial advisor Michael Taylor (Reiser) and free-spirited artist Joey Harris (Evigan) are reunited in Judge Margaret Wilbur’s (Stanley) office. 

At stake is the late Marcy Bradford’s last wishes, which bequeaths custody of her twelve-year-old daughter, Nicole (Keanan) to Nicole’s biologically indeterminate father(s).  Hence, Michael and Joey, as much as they dislike one another, now find themselves as co-parents of a pre-teen Nicole.

Initially living with free-spirited Joey, a grieving Nicole realizes she needs both her fathers in her suddenly upside-down life.  Despite her own doubts, a compassionate Judge Wilbur is willing to take a chance on it.

Michael Taylor: Paul Reiser

Joey Harris: Greg Evigan

Nicole Bradford: Staci Keanan

Judge Margaret W. Wilbur: Florence Stanley

Kathryn: Amanda Horan Kennedy (aka Barbara Horan)

Pizza Boy: Max Perlich

Notes: Prior to Greg Evigan’s theme song, “You Can Count on Me,” for the TV series, the pilot utilized a generic instrumental theme.  Series regular Florence Stanley is credited as a guest star.   

REVIEW:

Among the ultra-contrived TV sitcom premises of the mid-to-late 80’s, “My Two Dads” likely ranks near the top of that dubious list.  Aside from the ‘biologically indeterminate’ nonsense that a paternity test could easily resolve, how well does this pilot episode hold up thirty-six years later?  One ought to consider the answer a matter of degrees – not to mention, the show pitches more risqué humor than one might expect for a supposedly kid-friendly program.

Landing a few acerbic innuendos, sitcom veteran Florence Stanley steals her scenes as a no-nonsense family court judge.  Also brightening the episode is newcomer Staci Keanan, who makes the best of the eye-rolling storyline, as written.  Guest star Amanda Horan Kennedy’s charm helps carry the opening sequence, making it a shame that her character (as Michael’s an  attorney) never appeared again. 

Note: Emma Samms subsequently played Nicole’s late mother in a ‘dream’ episode.  In retrospect, Horan Kennedy would have been an ideal casting choice as ‘Marcy.’  Her coincidental resemblance to Keanan is frankly closer than Reiser, Evigan, or Samms – making the storyline’s who’s-the-father? concept a much easier sell to viewers.

The flip side, ironically, would be the efforts from co-leads Paul Reiser and Greg Evigan.  Evidently too eager to land his heavily-scripted retorts (a pause or two would have been helpful), Reiser should have dialed back his performance a notch.  Still, at least his tightly-wound yuppie comes off more believable than Evigan’s urban artist.  Beyond the ultra-implausible loft apartment ‘Joey’ somehow magically affords, it’s not Evigan’s fault that his impulsive character is such a grating and thinly-written cliché.  While Evigan enjoys good chemistry with Reiser and Keanan, his one-dimensional ‘Joey’ is this pilot’s biggest misstep.

All things considered, the first “My Two Dads” episode actually isn’t half-bad.  Suffice to say, the 80’s had some far more nauseating dreck posing as sitcoms – Small Wonder, anyone? 

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                         5 Stars

IMAGE NOT AVAILABLE

Categories
Digital Movies & TV Movies & Television (Videos) Online Videos Sports (TV & Videos) TV Series TV Series (Specific Episodes) WWF/WWE (Pro Wrestling)

“GORGEOUS” JIMMY GARVIN, WITH PRECIOUS VS. BRAD ARMSTRONG (NWA World Championship Wrestling: Aired 2-7-1987)

SUMMARY:          APPROX. RUNNING TIME:10:44 Min.

The match was taped at a house show, in either January or early February of 1987, from Washington, D.C.’s Armory.  The bout subsequently aired on February 7, 1987, for WTBS’ World Championship Wrestling TV series.  Garvin’s valet (and real-life spouse), Precious, is at ringside. 

The match’s commentators are Tony Schiavone and promoter David Crockett.   

REVIEW:

As a peripheral NWA main event attraction, Jimmy Garvin’s charismatic talents and flashy appearance convey that he and his blond valet, Precious, were the promotion’s answer to the WWF’s legendary “Macho Man” Randy Savage and Miss Elizabeth.  Predating Savage & Elizabeth’s mass popularity by a few years, the Garvin/Precious duo’s presence in the mid-to-late ‘80s NWA often made for some good viewing.  Case in point: Garvin’s brand of obnoxious heel tactics proves well-suited against the underrated Brad Armstrong. 

Despite such reliable in-ring work as a second-generation pro, Armstrong never got his own high-profile gimmick/angle to shine.  Though he would later be reduced into some under-the-radar masked roles, at least Armstrong was never publicly humiliated like Terry Taylor’s Red Rooster.  Armstrong, as seen in this bout, reminds viewers why he was among the NWA’s best technical performers by readily keeping up with Garvin’s star power.

Case in point: Armstrong’s match-ending hard fall to the arena’s parquet floor signifies his toughness by getting up fast.  This routine encounter isn’t likely to inspire multiple viewings, but it is all means watchable.       

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                    5½ Stars

IMAGE NOT AVAILABLE

Categories
Digital Movies & TV Movies & Television (Videos) Online Videos Sports (TV & Videos) TV Series TV Series (Specific Episodes) WWF/WWE (Pro Wrestling)

NWA U.S. TAG TEAM CHAMPION BARRY WINDHAM VS. ARN ANDERSON (NWA World Championship Wrestling: Aired 2-7-1987)

SUMMARY:         APPROX. RUNNING TIME: 12:13 Min.

Taped in either January or early February of 1987, this house show match from Philadelphia’s Civic Center was aired on February 7, 1987, for WTBS’ World Championship Wrestling TV series.  Appearing without his Four Horseman cronies, Arn Anderson (then half of the Minnesota Wrecking Crew with Ole Anderson) faces off against rival Barry Windham.  At the time, Windham shared half of the NWA’s U.S. Tag Team Championship with Ronnie Garvin. 

Providing the match’s commentary are Tony Schiavone and promoter David Crockett.

REVIEW:

Making it look easy, even an average Windham vs. Anderson match-up surpasses many of their contemporaries on their best days.  While this TV showdown might not inspire multiple viewings, the sweaty workmanship that Windham and Anderson put forth in this rugged bout is still commendable.  More so, one gets a welcome clean finish in this nostalgic NWA treat.          

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                    7 Stars

IMAGE NOT AVAILABLE

Categories
Digital Movies & TV Movies & Television (Videos) Online Videos Sports (TV & Videos) TV Series TV Series (Specific Episodes) WWF/WWE (Pro Wrestling)

NWA WORLD TV CHAMPION TULLY BLANCHARD, WITH JAMES J. DILLON VS. “THE AMERICAN DREAM” DUSTY RHODES (NWA World Championship Wrestling: Aired 2-7-1987)

SUMMARY:         APPROX. RUNNING TIME: 9:34 Min.

Taped in either January or early February of 1987, this title rematch from the Los Angeles Forum subsequently aired on February 7, 1987, for WTBS’ World Championship Wrestling TV series.  In a battle of perennial rivals, an extra stipulation is a supposed $10,000.00 cash prize offered by James J. Dillon of The Four Horsemen.  Also making appearances are Barry Windham and The Horsemen’s Arn Anderson.  

Providing the match’s commentary are Tony Schiavone and promoter David Crockett.

REVIEW:

Given it is a standard TV-caliber match, Rhodes and Blanchard at least supply some worthwhile viewing.  One amusing sequence stands out: Rhodes and Dillon first yank a ‘semi-conscious’ Blanchard in a tug-of-war; and then Rhodes ‘double-teams’ the World TV Champion and Dillon with a flurry of his patented “Bionic Elbows.”  Otherwise, one can expect the usual shenanigans (i.e., Anderson & Blanchard draw blood on Rhodes), plus an invariably cheap finish. 

Considering the players involved, this NWA World TV title defense serves a nostalgic treat for mid-80’s NWA fans.

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                        5½ Stars

IMAGE NOT AVAILABLE

Categories
Digital Movies & TV Movies & Television (Videos) Online Videos Sports (TV & Videos) TV Series TV Series (Specific Episodes) WWF/WWE (Pro Wrestling)

NWA WORLD CHAMPION “NATURE BOY” RIC FLAIR VS. NWA U.S. CHAMPION “THE RUSSIAN NIGHTMARE” NIKITA KOLOFF {No Disqualification Match} (NWA World Championship Wrestling: Aired 2-7-1987)

SUMMARY:          APPROX. RUNNING TIME: 32:33 Min.

Taped in either January or early February 1987, this no-disqualification title rematch from Starrcade ’86 pitting the NWA’s two top singles champions against one another takes place at the Coliseum in Charlotte, NC.  The bout subsequently aired on February 7, 1987, for WTBS’ World Championship Wrestling TV series. 

Late in the game, backing Flair is his nefarious Four Horsemen crony, Tully Blanchard.  Koloff’s ‘Superpowers’ tag team partner, “The American Dream” Dusty Rhodes, also makes an appearance to even the odds.   

REVIEW:

It is easy to recall Sting and Lex Luger as the greatest power wrestlers challenging Ric Flair’s NWA World Championship reign in the Late ‘80s.  Yet, Nikita Koloff, in his prime, was no slouch, either. 

Considering Koloff’s remarkable in-ring chemistry with Flair, one wonders why “The Russian Nightmare” did not serve a brief run as the NWA’s World Champion.  His powerhouse gimmick, suffice to say, was ideal for the old school NWA mindset that preferred wrestlers over live-action cartoons. 

Despite a predictably inconclusive finish, Koloff demonstrates that he could readily keep up with Flair’s renowned stamina for more than a half-hour.  Make no mistake: Flair and Koloff’s athletic choreography ages far better than sitting through one of Hulk Hogan’s sluggish WWF World Title defenses against Nikolai Volkoff.  Wrestling nostalgia buffs, if anything, should consider revisiting the mid-80’s Koloff-Flair feud as some of the best low-key NWA World Title clashes of that era. 

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                       7 Stars

IMAGE NOT AVAILABLE

Categories
Digital Movies & TV Movies & Television (Videos) Online Videos Sports (TV & Videos) TV Series TV Series (Specific Episodes) WWF/WWE (Pro Wrestling)

WCW LAST-MAN-STANDING, OVER-THE- TOP MILLIONAIRES’ CLUB VS. THE NEW BLOOD BATTLE ROYAL (WCW Thunder: Aired 5-3-2000)

SUMMARY:                 RUNNING TIME: Approx. 26:12 Min.

At the Mid-South Coliseum in Memphis, TN, this street fight battle royal served as the main event for WTBS’ WCW Thunder TV episode on May 3, 2000.  Reminiscent of the NWA’s anything-goes Bunkhouse Stampedes of the late ‘80’s, participants wear ‘street clothes’ and the New Blood faction brings blunt weapons of choice.  Baited by “Nature Boy” Ric Flair, the New Blood’s Eric Bischoff agrees that the last-standing participant scores a WCW World Heavyweight Championship title shot at the Great American Bash Pay-Per-View the following month. 

The vastly outnumbered Millionaires’ Club is led by Flair.  Joining him are “Diamond” Dallas Page; Sting; Hulk Hogan; “The Total Package” Lex Luger; Curt Hennig; Horace Hogan; “Hacksaw” Jim Duggan; Chris Kanyon; Hugh Morrus; and KroniK (Brian Adams & Bryan Clark).

With 20-25 guys, Bischoff and Vince Russo’s New Blood army consists of: Jeff Jarrett; Billy Kidman; Harlem Heat’s quartet (including Booker T, Stevie Ray, & Tony Norris – the WWE’s ex-“Ahmed Johnson”); Tank Abbott; Mike Awesome; Van Hammer; Ernest “The Cat” Miller; Chris Candido; Shawn Stasiak; Marcus Bagwell; Vampiro; Scott Steiner; Konnan; Johnny the Bull; Disco Inferno; The Wall; Bam Bam Bigelow; The Harris Brothers; and Norman Smiley. 

Additional guest stars includes: Bret “Hitman” Hart; Madusa; Mona; Asya; Tammy Lynn Sytch; and, in his final WCW appearance, “Macho Man” Randy Savage (who had abruptly exited WCW soon after Road Wild ’99).  Ominously mentioned as ‘locked away’ by Russo, Miss Elizabeth does not appear.   

The match’s commentary team consists of Tony Schiavone, Bobby “The Brain” Heenan, & “Iron” Mike Tenay.

Notes: As a parental advisory, this free-for-all includes man vs. woman violence.  RE: stars not included: for The Millionaires’ Club, among them are Kevin Nash, Sid Vicious, Rick Steiner, & Barry Windham; for the New Blood, one could mention, for instance, Chuck Palumbo, Mark Jindrak, and Sean O’Haire. Goldberg’s absence, at the time, was due to an extended injury leave.

REVIEW:

Let’s review the backstory first.  By mid-2000 (WCW’s last full year of operation), World Championship Wrestling was in freefall, both creatively and financially.  Out of desperation, a hapless WCW rehired ex-boss Eric Bischoff and one of his failed successors, Vince Russo, to co-manage the promotion; this uneasy partnership, suffice to say, lasted a few months.   

Their short-lived ‘big idea’ was to vacate all championships and forcibly reboot the company in a variation of its profitable 1996-99 WCW vs. New World Order (NWO) mega-feud.  Including several of its biggest-name NWO alumni, the company’s aging main eventers (aka ‘The Millionaires’ Club’) were pitched as lumbering yet sympathetic babyfaces. 

The snarky villains would be WCW’s suppressed young talent, with veterans Jeff Jarrett and Shane Douglas cast as its in-ring leadership.  Predictably, Russo and Bischoff doubled as the New Blood’s gloating on-screen masterminds.

As with Bischoff’s NWO, such a concept had been lifted from Japan, so there was a successful precedent.  Further, pitting two wrestling generations’ legitimate resentment/animosity against one other seemingly made good sense on paper, at least from WCW’s perspective.    

Here’s the rub: Ted Turner’s WCW too often didn’t grasp long-term planning, let alone foresee fallout from ultra-stupid booking (i.e., 1990’s Capitol Combat: The Return of Robocop).  Once Bischoff and Hulk Hogan transformed WCW into their hugely expensive playground, such bone-headed decision-making gradually shifted to the rule vs. being forgiven as misguided exceptions. 

Case in point: subsequently ceding creative authority to an ultra-selfish Hogan and Kevin Nash, among others, a series of ludicrous programming blunders became the obvious culprit for WCW’s eroding fanbase. Still, if all went well, this overbooked Bunkhouse Stampede featuring nearly the entire roster would then justify how Russo & Bischoff programmed WCW’s upcoming summer Pay-Per-Views.    

Spelling out WCW’s dumpster fire mentality, unfortunately, this grungy, all-star gang warfare is best skipped.  Veterans, such as Page, Jarrett, and even a fifty-year-old Flair (in a dress shirt and slacks, no less), muster decent fight choreography for TV.  It isn’t nearly enough to overcome Russo & Bischoff’s blatant disrespect for pro wrestling fans’ intelligence.  Whatever their motives were, this smug duo appears on-screen practically gleeful peddling trash to disinterested WCW audiences.      

For instance, despite the varying camera angles, it is impossible to tell which unaffiliated ‘mercenary’ is on which side – invariably, some even switch sides. More so, the match’s chaotic nature doesn’t show when or how several participants (especially late-comers) enter and/or leave the ring. Perhaps these confusing match elements were meant as bits of shades-of-gray realism, but they certainly fall short of watchability.

One element, however, is inevitable: WCW’s tone-deaf squandering of mega-star talent on its payroll, especially as outside inference.  For instance: off WCW television since Fall 1999, a jacked-up, 47-year-old Savage’s unexpected return initially pays off.  Yet, Savage’s half-hearted series of running double-ax handles on the opposition implies how far his renowned mobility had diminished.  Teasing that the “Macho Man” had resumed active duty, his one-shot presence leads to nothing – aside from a brief reunion of the Mega-Powers.

Another unnecessary eyesore is Bret Hart’s own brief contribution.  To epitomize his disappointing WCW tenure, Hart’s chair-swinging actions, let alone his murky allegiance, make no sense to the supposed plot.  Lastly, the company’s worst sleaze is the New Blood’s gang-style violence perpetrated against female wrestlers (and vice-versa).   Faked or not, such visuals come off as an utterly putrid display packaged as so-called “entertainment.”

If anything, this ugly battle royal is a master class in wasting the still-considerable talent pool that WCW had under contract – both its past-their-prime legends and the supposedly rising New Blood horde. 

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                  1½ Stars

IMAGE NOT AVAILABLE

Categories
Digital Movies & TV Movies & Television (Videos) Online Videos Sports (TV & Videos) TV Series TV Series (Specific Episodes) WWF/WWE (Pro Wrestling)

THE ROAD WARRIORS (HAWK & ANIMAL), WITH PAUL ELLERING VS. THE MIDNIGHT EXPRESS (“PLAYBOY” DENNIS CONDREY & “BEAUTIFUL BOBBY EATON), WITH JIM CORNETTE & BIG BUBBA ROGERS {Scaffold Match} (NWA World Championship Wrestling: Aired 2-7-1987)

SUMMARY:             APPROX. RUNNING TIME: 9:00 Min.

Taped in either January or early February 1987, this scaffold rematch from Starrcade ’86 (with all the same players) occurs at the Los Angeles Forum.  The bout subsequently aired on February 7, 1987, for WTBS’ World Championship Wrestling TV series.  Per the match’s stipulations, both tag team partners must fall from the scaffold devised above the ring for the other team to prevail. 

From Jim Cornette’s purported description of the Starrcade ’86 bout, the NWA’s scaffold set-up was an estimated twenty-five feet off the arena floor, as compared to about twenty feet above the ring’s mat.  Provided a six-foot wrestler is precariously hanging beneath the scaffold at his full outstretched height, one is still looking, at best, at a fourteen-foot drop.  

REVIEW:

As Cornette had gruesomely blown out his knee in a botched scaffold stunt a few months earlier at Starrcade ’86, it’s no surprise that his contributions are restricted to taunting.  Later rebranded as the WWF’s Big Boss Man, Big Bubba’s menacing presence amounts to nothing this time.  The same applies to Hawk & Animal’s manager, Paul Ellering. 

If anything, Condrey and Eaton’s initially on-screen leeriness is justifiable – as if anybody really wants to plunge the equivalent off the roof of a house, with little to no padding waiting below.  Given such enormous risk, stunt work in scaffold matches conveys 250+-pound guys straddling a tightrope, and this ultra-predictable bout is no exception. 

The good news is that the losers had prior experience taking such perilous falls and managed to evade injury – lucky them.  Conversely, despite its star power, this “Night of the Skywalkers” rematch struggles to be watchable. 

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                       4 Stars

IMAGE NOT AVAILABLE

Categories
Digital Movies & TV Movies & Television (Videos) Online Videos Sports (TV & Videos) TV Episodes & Movies TV Series WWF/WWE (Pro Wrestling)

UWF TAG TEAM CHAMPIONS THE SHEEPHERDERS (LUKE WILLIAMS & BUTCH MILLER), WITH JACK VICTORY VS. THE FANTASTICS (TOMMY ROGERS & BOBBY FULTON) (UWF Television: Taped 3-30-1986)

SUMMARY:                     RUNNING TIME: 15:01 Min.

Taped at a Tulsa, Oklahoma convention center, on March 30, 1986, this UWF (Universal Wrestling Federation) tag team title defense pits champions The Sheepherders (Luke Williams & Butch Miller) vs. the newly-arrived Fantastics (Tommy Rogers & Bobby Fulton).  Along with the Sheepherders’ New Zealand flag-waving crony, Jack Victory, at ringside, the TV taping’s commentary team consists of Jim Ross & promotion owner Bill Watts.

This match was evidently televised on April 5, 1986. 

Notes:  For their entrance music, The Fantastics then shared ZZ Top’s “Sharp-Dressed Man” with “Gorgeous” Jimmy Garvin (coincidentally, a fellow aficionado of sequined-heavy entrance attire).  A few years later, the veteran Sheepherders were rebranded by the WWF as the cartoony ‘Bushwhackers.’

REVIEW:

It’s not hard to visualize: the Sheepherders’ plodding villainy vs. Rogers & Fulton’s charismatic, fast-paced offense (after discarding their bowties & sleeveless tuxedo jackets).  A likable finish serves as the best twist, given how routine this title bout is – i.e., the subdued audience is telling. 

Seeing the underrated Fantastics in their prime, however, makes one imagine how they might have fared in Vince McMahon’s muscle-heavy WWF.  As light heavyweights, their flashy babyface style resembled Stan Lane & Steve Keirn’s Fabulous Ones of the early-to-mid 80’s, including their Chippendale physiques.  Yet, Fulton & Rogers were noticeably shorter than the Rockers and not nearly as power-packed as the British Bulldogs (who rivaled them, height-wise).  Overall, their closest WWF talent equivalent of that era would have been the Killer Bees. 

Instead of their hot 1988 NWA U.S. Tag Team Title feud against Jim Cornette’s Midnight Express, Fulton & Rogers likely would have suffered as glorified WWF jobbers.  Sharing such duties with Jim Powers & Paul Roma’s Young Stallions is a fair guess, as compared to the more teen-friendly and ultra-athletic Rockers’ success.  Come 1989-90, the Fantastics and the wily Sheepherders/Bushwhackers would have then been stuck outflanking one another as fan favorites in the WWF’s mid-card doghouse.

From a fan’s perspective, watching the Fantastics against their perpetual rivals, the Midnight Express, in any league (Mid-South/UWF, World Class, NWA, etc.) is far preferable, in terms of welcome unpredictability.  Still, catching the agile Fulton & Rogers here during their ten-month UWF stint is a nostalgic treat.  Their watchable chemistry with the future Bushwhackers makes this tag team championship bout worth a single viewing. 

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                       5 Stars

IMAGE NOT AVAILABLE

Categories
Digital Documentaries Digital Movies & TV History & Biographies (Videos) Movies & Television (Videos) Online Videos TV Episodes & Movies TV Series TV Series (Specific Episodes)

BRAD MELTZER’S DECODED: THE MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF BILLY THE KID (Season 2: Episode 6)

SUMMARY:              RUNNING TIME: Approx. 44:16 Min.

This episode premiered on The History Channel on November 23, 2011.  Hosted in-studio by novelist Brad Meltzer, his investigative team consists of: mechanical engineer/author Christine McKinley; attorney (and now a circuit court judge) Scott Rolle; and professor/author Buddy Levy. 

Revisiting pivotal New Mexico sites during the last months of Billy the Kid’s life, Meltzer’s investigators probe alternate theories re: whether Lincoln County Sheriff Pat Garrett indeed killed the Kid (aka William H. Bonney/Antrim/McCarty) on the night of July 14, 1881. 

Cause for skepticism primarily stems from the Meltzer team’s efforts to debunk some of Garrett’s claims ultimately leading to the Kid’s death: i.e., on April 28, 1881, why did Garrett fatefully (or perhaps conveniently) leave town on county business prior to the Kid’s deadly jailbreak?  How were the sheriff’s security precautions breached, so the shackled Kid could readily access a firearm?  Months later, at Pete Maxwell’s home, how could the Kid have slipped past Garrett’s two deputies standing guard outside before meeting his fate against Garrett in a darkened bedroom?     

Guests interviewed are: historian Mark Lee Gardner; retired police officer Steven Sederwall (who supervises a forensics test re: Deputy Bell’s murder during the Kid’s escape); author W. C. Jameson; two of Garrett’s grandchildren: Savannah & J.P. Garrett; and two of the Kid’s purported descendants: great-grandson Elbert Garcia and second cousin-once-removed Elaine McReynolds.

Meltzer’s team further examines Garrett’s veracity, as to the Kid’s infamous jail breakout killing two deputies, let alone the theory that an obstructive scheme shielded Garrett’s supposed killing of the wrong man in the Kid’s place.  Also contemplated is the likelihood of whether elderly Ollie “Brushy Bill” Roberts (one of innumerable mid-20th Century Kid claimants) was the authentic Kid, as based upon photographic analysis technology and eyewitness accounts. 

Further, several uncredited reenactment segments are included.

REVIEW:

Without passing judgment on the series itself, this episode proves watchable.  Even its most dubious speculations are more plausible than, say, America Unearthed’s “Lost Secrets of the Alamo Revealed” episode, which dubiously pitches Davy Crockett’s alleged survival into old age in a secluded corner of Alabama. 

Veering between theories that long-time buddies Garrett and the Kid had conspired together to fake the outlaw’s death (in an everybody-wins scenario), or that Garrett’s less-than-heroic version (despite its logical flaws) is basically correct, Meltzer’s presentation of disputed history is generally fair.  His cohorts also convey an articulate pendulum weighing alternative answers explaining Garrett and the Kid’s final showdown. Yet, Meltzer’s advocation for sensationalizing conspiracy theories is excessive, which obstructs his program’s own credibility.

Though 1990’s Young Guns II, is not specifically mentioned, several elements of the film’s premise and plotting are mirrored throughout this episode.  Hence, fans of Young Guns II should enjoy “Billy the Kid’s Mysterious Death.”  Most others will deem the truth behind the Kid’s demise still muddled – as Meltzer’s show readily stirs the unprovable conspiracy pot.    

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                 5½ Stars

IMAGE NOT AVAILABLE

Categories
Digital Documentaries Digital Movies & TV Movies & Television (Videos) Online Videos TV Episodes & Movies TV Series TV Series (Specific Episodes)

AMERICA UNEARTHED: LOST SECRETS OF THE ALAMO REVEALED (Season 3: Episode 1)

SUMMARY:              RUNNING TIME: Approx. 43:00 Min.

This episode first aired on The History Channel on November 8, 2014.  Hosted by forensic geologist-author Scott Wolter, the premise is not about The Alamo itself.  Rather, the theory is: what if Davy Crockett survived the Battle of the Alamo? 

Wolter probes the claim of a local family in Double Springs, Alabama, in possession of three documents, including an 1859 land deed from U.S. President James Buchanan indicating a David Crockett purchased and then lived on their future property for the remainder of his life.  Wolter subsequently coordinates an excavation of this property with Search₂O archaeologist Mike Arbuthonot’s group searching for relevant artifacts, including Crockett’s possible gravesite.

Wolter further explores the frontiersman’s background by visiting The Alamo, as well as interviewing one of Crockett’s 4th great-granddaughters: Joy Bland, in Rutherford, Tennessee.  Another Wolter interview is with Crockett biographer Michael Wallis at The Alamo.  Freemason expert Jack Roberts, in Minneapolis, offers his input on Crockett’s purported status as a Freemason.  Battle reenactments (featuring Jeremy Frandup as ‘Crockett’ and Ludy Webster as ‘General Santa Anna’) are frequently replayed.

Based upon his interpretation of circumstantial evidence, Wolter ultimately concludes there is at least a possibility that Crockett relocated to Alabama after his supposed death.  

REVIEW:

Unmistakably, this slickly-produced documentary is peddling tabloid speculation worthy of The National Enquirer.  For instance, by implying Crockett possibly faked his death like Jesse James and other historical figures accused of the same, the episode tries to stoke controversy amongst the most gullible. Epitomizing this episode’s ridiculous premise is what the excavation team actually uncovers in their dramatic dig (here’s a hint: it’s a called a buried rock).  

Other than offering a bizarre theory that General Santa Anna (as a fellow Freemason) inexplicably spared Crockett’s life, there is zero proof explaining how Crockett would have survived past March 6, 1836.  Given this bleak certainty, the consensus from Scott Wolter’s interviews fails to justify his illogical suppositions that Crockett could have secretly resurfaced in Alabama.    

Had the episode’s narrative merely conveyed that Crockett’s murky fate is reminiscent of Butch Cassidy and The Sundance Kid (whose remains were never conclusively located), that assertion is far closer to common sense.  The same applies to biographer Michael Wallis’ belief that, if he was captured as a P.O.W., Crockett was then summarily executed, post-battle, by Santa Anna’s forces.  As the Alamo defenders’ remains were burned in mass, the dubious outcome of the excavation team’s search for Crockett’s unmarked grave in Alabama is unsurprising.      

A reenactment sequence of Crockett displaying a Freemason surrender gesture that Santa Anna mercifully accepts, is, therefore, ludicrous.  More so, Wolter’s instant acceptance of mid-19th Century documents supposedly signed by Crockett (especially the all-too-modern-looking ‘April 1836 Cincinnati Whig’ news clipping stating Crockett had survived his battle wounds) comes off as utterly blind wishful thinking rather than applying sufficient critical analysis.  Notably, Wolter’s careful sidestepping of Mike Arbuthonot’s logical theory that the land deed’s scribbled signature belongs to some mid-19th Century local also named ‘David Crockett’ speaks for itself. 

Wolter makes valid points re: why a person’s signature can worsen over time, but this episode’s compelling new ‘evidence,’ is still flimsy and highly implausible. Even worse, such what-if speculation shamelessly insults a viewer’s intelligence. Why The History Channel would risk its credibility on such sensationalistic garbage says a lot about its programming choices.

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                        2 Stars

IMAGE NOT AVAILABLE