Written Matthew Struges & (See Below)
Art by Freddie Williams II; Richard & Tanya Horie; Rob Leigh; & (See Below)
Cover Art by Freddie Williams II
SUMMARY:
Released by DC Comics for January 2010, this 80-page one-shot has the JSA’s brownstone HQ mystically rocked from within by spatial-time anomalies. The team roster includes: Wildcat, Stargirl, Damage, Mr. Terrific II, Lightning (Jennifer Pierce), Cyclone, Tomcat, Judomaster, Dr. Mid-Nite III, & Damage. Dividing into trios, various JSA teammates are pushed into bizarre, possibly hallucinatory scenarios. Ultimately, they’re caught up in twists (if not, tales) of Fate.
- Memory Lane. Writer: James Robinson, with Art by: Neil Edwards; Wayne Faucher; Mike Thomas & Rob Leigh. The teenage Cyclone (Maxine Hunkle) awkwardly relays to the current Mr. America how her grandmother, Ma Hunkel, first met Tex Thompson – the original Mr. America back in 1939.
- Heart of Steel. Writer: Felicia D. Henderson, with Art by: Renato Guedes; José Wilson Magalhaes; Rob Leigh; & David Curiel. While Stargirl, Cyclone, Damage, Judomaster, Tomcat, & King Chimera battle glass creatures on the HQ rooftop, a rattled Citizen Steel senses his metallicized mother and brother reaching out to him.
- Amazing Grace. Writer: Kevin Grevioux, with Art by: Roberto Castro; John Floyd; Rob Leigh; & Hi-Fi. After Wildcat & Mr. Terrific II stumble upon Dr. Fate’s meditation room, Markus Clay/Amazing Man is transported elsewhere. Trapped with civilians in a New Orleans basement laundry room with a horrific monster rampaging outside, Clay discovers a new secret of his magic.
- Mother’s Little Secret. Writer/Artist: Jerry Ordway, with Additional Art by: Hi-Fi; Rob Leigh; & Mike Carlin. Separating from Damage & Judomaster, Tomcat ventures into the brownstone attic. He is somehow propelled into a time-warp revealing secrets of his parentage. Both the original Dr. Mid-Nite and the Golden Age Huntress makes guest appearances.
- Spin Cycle. Writer: Jen Van Meter, with Art by: Jesus Merino; Jesse Delperoang; Rob Leigh; & Allen Passalqua. In the team’s laundry room, teenager Cyclone catches up with Power Girl for some girl talk. Yet, saving Wildcat (and his newfound prize) from an annoyed Icicle takes priority.
- Damage. Writer: Zander Gannon, with Art by: Scott Hampton; Danny Vozzo; & Rob Leigh. Separated from Judomaster, Damage finds himself literally in the dark on Dr. Mid-Nite’s operating table. At stake are removing some of his old personal demons, including Zoom.
REVIEW:
There’s dual upshots: 1. The artwork is high-caliber, and 2. 80 pages for these visuals. As for the scripting, “meh” pretty much covers it. While DC’s 80-page Giant anthology specials can be intriguing reads, this one is a mixed bag – some characters (i.e. Wildcat) are allotted too much screen time while others (i.e. Lightning) are inexplicably assigned nothing to do.
The ‘haunted house’ plot’s bookend framework works okay, as far as keeping fans tuned in. Yet, these six interconnected tales go off in such wonky tangents that maintaining coherency is clearly a chore for the writers. Case in point: only Jerry Ordway’s easy-to-follow “Mother’s Little Secret” conveys a relatable sense of poignancy, let alone spikes sympathy for one of the JSA’s new generation characters.
Cyclone’s semi-naïve chat with Power Girl re: her costume’s distracting trademark is also well-played — but the rest of “Spin Cycle” is an eye-roller re: fallout from Wildcat & Icicle’s pinocle game (seriously). The other four tales similarly come off as glorified filler.
Justice Society of America 80-Page Giant # 1 is really meant for the franchise’s die-hards – specifically, those who like keeping track of the JSA’s cumbersome roster. Otherwise, the practical reason to keep this issue is for excellent DC artwork, i.e. the striking cover image.
ADDITIONAL CONTENT:
There’s a full-page “DC Nation” column.
BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING: 6 Stars