Categories
Comic Books & Graphic Novels DC Comics

CONVERGENCE: CATWOMAN # 1 (2015 DC Comics)

Written by Justin Gray

Art by Ron Randall; Gabe Eltaeb; & Pat Brosseau

Cover Art by Claire Wendling

SUMMARY:

Released by DC Comics for June 2015, the first half of this two-part tale is entitled “Schrödinger’s Cat.”  For the past year, an interrupted heist has left Selina Kyle/Catwoman trapped in Metropolis within the impenetrable dome.  In a city without super-heroes, she is single-handedly defending Suicide Slum from increasing depredations by Bruno Mannheim’s ruthless Intergang.  Taking down a gang of armored thugs, she wryly notes that Batman’s influence has upgraded her fighting style.  Elsewhere, Mannheim brutally kills an expendable informant before dispatching the corpse to his piranha tank.

As Intergang continues hoarding the city’s vital resources, Selina tries rescuing an abducted scientist that Suicide Slum desperately needs for its survival.  Escaping from Intergang’s retaliatory firepower, Selina hears the dome’s unknown creator finally speak.  Setting up the concluding Issue # 2, someone from Kingdom Come’s alternate reality approaches a wary Selina.  The question remains: is this armored Batman an ally or Catwoman’s latest foe?       

Note: Though an image isn’t provided, the variant cover artists are Chip Kidd, Jim Balent, & Ande Parks.

REVIEW:

Writer Justin Gray does commendable work revisiting Selina’s popular 1990’s persona, including her masked purple-and-black catsuit.  Tightly focusing on the Catwoman vs. Intergang feud, Gray pushes his plot forward in a satisfying manner.  To his credit, Gray leaves Selina’s fans stoked to seek out Issue # 2

In terms of the high-caliber visuals, the art squad homages Selina’s first solo title with plenty of class.  Suffice to say, Convergence: Catwoman # 1 is both a satisfying read and a welcome dose of ‘90s nostalgia.

ADDITIONAL CONTENT:

There’s a two-page summary of Selina’s exploits from her original solo series (1993-2001).  The “DC All Access” column hypes the Blu-Ray/DVD release of the Batman vs. Robin animated film.    

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                   8 Stars

Categories
DC-Related Individual Tracks (CD's) Music & Radio Shows Soundtracks (CD's)

DC LEGENDS OF TOMORROW TV THEME (by Blake Neely: Music of DC Comics, Volume 2)

SUMMARY:                              RUNNING TIME: 0:50 Min.

This track appears on 2016’s Music of DC Comics, Volume 2.  Courtesy of composer-conductor Blake Neely, this opening credits instrumental accompanies the DC Legends of Tomorrow live-action TV series.      

REVIEW:

Given a duly epic sound, this DC Legends of Tomorrow theme is terrific for what little listeners get.  The disappointment is that the tune seems several seconds too short, even for a contemporary TV instrumental.  One could also readily argue that there’s nothing distinctive to clue in non-fans, especially re: which DC heroes this track is meant for.  Even so, for Legends fans, this instrumental is worth adding to a favorite playlist. 

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                         6 Stars

Categories
Comic Books & Graphic Novels Marvel Comics MARVEL's Hardcovers & Paperbacks

WOMEN OF MARVEL, VOLUME 1 (MARVEL Comics)

Written by (See Below)

Art by (See Below)

Compilation Cover Art by Mike Mayhew

SUMMARY:

Released in 2006 by Marvel Comics, this 224-page retrospective compiles the following ten comics, which sometimes doubles as a character’s crime-fighting debut (see *).

  • The Amazing Spider-Man # 86 (1970) – “Beware … The Black Widow!” Writer: Stan Lee, with Art by: John Romita; Jim Mooney; & Sam Rosen.  Debuting her trademark black jumpsuit, Black Widow attempts to learn the secret of Spider-Man’s powers.  Meanwhile, an injured Peter Parker fears that he is permanently losing his powers.
  • *The Cat # 1 (1972) – “Beware the Claws of the Cat!”  Writers: Linda Fite & Roy Thomas, with Art by: Marie Severin; Wally Wood; & John Costanza.  Before she became Tigra and passed on the costume to Patsy Walker’s Hellcat, young widow Greer Nelson was the masked Cat.  Seeking to avenge her now-deceased mentor, the Cat infiltrates their psychotic benefactor’s Chicago high-rise to ruin his plans for a mesmerized army of enhanced female Cats.  Greer’s origin as the Cat is revealed. 
  • *Shanna the She-Devil # 1 (1972) – “Shanna the She-Devil.”  Co-Writers: Carole Seuling & Steve Gerber, with Art by: George Tuska; Vincent Colletta; & John Costanza.  Including her origin, Dr. Shanna Hara is now the compassionate protector of jungle animals.  With her adopted jungle cats, she fiercely guards the African wilderness from nefarious ivory poachers out to kill a herd of elephants.
  • *Ms. Marvel # 1 (1972) – “This Woman, This Warrior!” Writer: Gerry Conway, with Art by: John Buscema; Joe Sinnott; Marie Severin; & John Costanza.  Spinning out of Marvel’s original Captain Marvel series, Carol Danvers is hired as J. Jonah Jameson’s new magazine editor.  Plagued by partial amnesia, Carol and her heroic alter-ego, Ms. Marvel, are unaware of each other.  Mary Jane Watson guest-stars, as Ms. Marvel must rescue an abducted J. Jonah from the Scorpion’s wrath.  Peter Parker and Robbie Robertson appear in Daily Bugle cameos.
  • *Dazzler # 1 (1976) – “So Bright This Star.”  Writer: Tom DeFalco, with Art by: John Romita Jr.; Alfredo Alcala; Glynis Wein; & Joe Rosen.  Alison Blaire needs a quick career boost, as she unknowingly crosses path with a new rival: Asgard’s nefarious Enchantress.  Guest stars include: Spider-Man; The X-Men (Storm, Wolverine, Colossus, Nightcrawler, & Kitty Pryde); & The Avengers (The Beast; Captain America; Iron Man; & the Wasp).    
  • The Uncanny X-Men # 151-152 (1981) – “X-Men Minus One! / The Hellfire Gambit.”  Writer: Chris Claremont, with Art by: Jim Sherman; Bob McLeod; Josef Rubenstein; Bonnie Wilford; Don Warfield; Tom Orzechowski; & Janice Chiang.  Taking advantage of Kitty Pryde’s departure, the Hellfire Club, along with multiple Sentinels, attacks the X-Mansion.  Among those taken captive are Cyclops, Nightcrawler, Colossus, and Wolverine.  Even worse, having secretly body-swapped with Storm, Emma Frost infiltrates the X-Men.  Kitty may be the team’s last hope.
  • Avengers # 221 (1982) – “New Blood.” Writers: Jim Shooter & David Michelinie; with Art by: Bob Hall; Brett Breeding; Christie Scheele; & Janice Chiang.  Seeking to boost the team roster, Thor approaches Spider-Man while  Captain America & Iron Man check up on Hawkeye.  The Wasp hosts an afternoon party attended by Black Widow; Spider-Woman (Jessica Drew); the She-Hulk; the Invisible Woman; and Dazzler.  One of them becomes a first-time Avenger.      
  • Uncanny X-Men # 182 (1984) – “Madness.”  Writer: Chris Claremont, with Art by: John Romita Jr.; Dan Green; Glynis Wein; & Tom Orzechowski.  Overwhelmed by Carol Danvers’ stolen memories, Rogue instinctively rescues  battered SHIELD agent Michael Rossi from homicide aboard its own heli-carrier.  However, Rossi is Ms. Marvel’s one-time lover, and he has no idea of Rogue’s bizarre connection to his beloved Carol.

*Uncanny X-Men # 244 (1989) – “Ladies Night.”  Writer: Chris Claremont, with Art by: Marc Silvestri; Dan Green; Glynis Wein; & Tom Orzechowski.  Introducing Jubilee, this X-tale has its female members (Storm, Dazzler, Psylocke, & Rogue) enjoying downtime at a glamorous L.A. mall.  Complicating the fun is the M-Squad (think Ghostbusters-meets-the original X-Factor team), as these bumbling mutant hunters are hired to capture perpetual mallrat Jubilee.      

Note: A sequel, Women of Marvel, Volume 2 is also available in paperback form.

REVIEW:

There’s a welcome surplus of early-to-mid ‘70s pro-feminism inhabiting this collection’s first half.  All good intentions aside, these dated adventures deliver some kid-friendly nostalgia that holds up okay by contemporary standards.  The visuals are consistently good quality – safely in the mid-B range.  The sole detriment that could be construed as predictably sexist are the heroines’ skimpy and/or skintight costumes. 

Among the oldest stories, Ms. Marvel’s debut works best, as it presents the partially-amnesiac Carol Danvers as a promising new heroine with instant star appeal.  The Spider-Man crossover is an ingenious move by having Ms. Marvel first tangle with a reliable Spider-baddie in the Scorpion.  By contrast, Dazzler’s solo debut is hampered by its overload of guest stars, which makes obvious that Marvel lacked confidence in this X-Men spin-off’s sales potential.  

Re: the book’s second half, most notably, Chris Claremont’s two-part X-Men tale is a welcome gem from forty years ago.  It has everything that X-fans enjoy about that era. Even if it isn’t the best-written, the all-star Avengers romp is undoubtedly the most fun to read, as far as some Marvel-style humor.

That leaves the last two X-Men tales.  Short of hardcore Rogue fans, “Madness” is worth exploring once, but its Carol Danvers memory-siphoning plot is creepier than actually being entertaining.  As for “Ladies Night,” depending on a given reader’s mood, either the story is an amusingly light-hearted X-caper meant as filler, or it’s just plain insipid – take your pick.      

Marvel admirably goes to the effort of freshening up the archival artwork, so one can’t complain about the top-flight production values.  For old-school fans, Women of Marvel, Volume 1 works its magic – long before these characters’ lives become excessively convoluted for casual enjoyment.  

ADDITIONAL CONTENT:

The covers are re-produced in a full-page format.  The artists aren’t credited, at least beyond what little can be read off each image.  The last page shows the artistic evolution of Mayhew’s compilation cover.

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                   7 Stars

Categories
Comic Books & Graphic Novels DC Comics DC's Hardcovers & Trade Paperbacks

INUSTICE 2, VOLUME 6 (DC Comics)

Written by Tom Taylor

Art by Bruno Redondo; Daniel Sampere; Xermanico; Juan Albarran; Rex Lokus; Gabe Eltaeb; J. Nanjan; John Kalisz; & Wes Abbott

Compilation Cover Art & Original Issue Cover Art by Bruno Redondo & Alejandro Sanchez

SUMMARY:

Released by DC Comics in 2019, this 184-page compilation consists of Injustice 2 # 31-36 and Annual # 2 from 2018-19.  In Injustice’s alternate reality, this volume serves up a final prequel leading into the Injustice 2 video game.  With planet Oa besieged by Starro-controlled Red Lanterns, the Green Lantern Corps is met by a Titans strike team (Superboy, Wonder Girl, Starfire, Lobo, Jaime Reyes’ Blue Beetle, & Booster Gold). 

Against such overwhelming odds in intergalactic combat, the Corps allows Oan prisoners ex-Yellow Lanterns Hal Jordan and Sinestro to reclaim emerald rings.  Even a sliced-in-half Lobo is recruited into this makeshift Green Lantern Corps  Wonder Girl and Superboy fatefully encounter Brainiac in deep space.  Jaime & Booster make a desperate last chase after an elusive Starro, as its next conquest will be Earth.

The Suicide Squad visits Ra’s Al Ghul’s Gorilla City to attend the wedding of Killer Croc and Orca.  Brainiac makes his move to recruit Grodd’s insurgents into a sinister pact.  Including Ra’s Al Ghul, U.S. President Jefferson Pierce, and Aquaman, the world’s feuding world powers are cajoled by Harley Quinn (of all people, no less) to make some sense of peace on Earth. 

In Gotham City, Alfred informs Bruce Wayne & Selina Kyle of a heartbreaking choice.  While Brainiac’s sinister Gorilla City alliance continues assembling, a flashback harkens back to eight years before.  Deadshot’s near-assassination of Bruce at Wayne Manor necessitates Selina, Alfred, and a recuperating Bruce hiding out with the Kents in Smallville.  

With help from Oracle’s team, Lois Lane (resembling Man of Steel’s Amy Adams) & Superman pursue Deadshot’s clients.  Proving that she doesn’t need super-powers, Lois demonstrates that she is a force of nature in her own right. Back in the present-day, Bruce shares a private chat with Jonathan Kent while Martha Kent visits their imprisoned son.  The final scene depicts Bruce & Clark’s shared pain over a world without Lois Lane. 

REVIEW:

Fans won’t likely be disappointed.  Volume 6 delivers a last dose of Injustice’s combustible formula of hardcore violence and wistful poignancy.  Despite plenty of implied gore, writer Tom Taylor’s scripting somehow remains credible in heartfelt scenes – i.e. juxtaposing its well-played flashback to a grim, present-day world missing Lois. 

A glaringly out-of-place element early on, however, is the unnecessary inclusion of Lobo’s perverted antics.  Suffice to say, implied obscenities he conjures with a power ring aren’t hard to fathom.  All readers actually see is one blurred emerald image – the shape is plainly obvious what it’s supposed to be.  Beyond over-indulging crude humor at this juncture, Taylor generally stays on his game through this volume.

Though the inconclusive finish isn’t satisfying (i.e. all the various loose ends awaiting in the video game), the art squad’s visuals are still consistently first-class.  Case in point: the flashback sequence’s artwork is excellent.

For Injustice fans, no matter if it isn’t the franchise’s best installment, Volume 6 is a means worth reading to the end.

ADDITIONAL CONTENT:

Bruno Redondo’s designs for Green Lantern Lobo are included.  Cover sketches-in-progress for Injustice 2 # 31-32 and # 34-36, as well as Annual # 2, are seen in black-and-white.

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                               7 Stars

Categories
Comic Books & Graphic Novels Marvel Comics MARVEL's Hardcovers & Paperbacks STAR WARS-Related

STAR WARS, VOLUME 1: SKYWALKER STRIKES (MARVEL Comics)

Written by Jason Aaron

Art by John Cassady; Laura Martin; & Chris Eliopoulos

Cover Art by John Cassaday & Laura Martin

SUMMARY:

Released by Marvel Comics in 2016, this 160-page compilation reprints Star Wars # 1-6 from 2015.  Leia’s squad (Han Solo, Chewbacca, Luke Skywalker, R2-D2-, & C-3PO) infiltrate a vital Imperial munitions factory on Cymoon 1 in the Corellia system.  Rescuing dozens of prisoners and explosive sabotage won’t be enough for the Rebels to escape Darth Vader’s furious wrath. 

Chewbacca, as a Rebel sniper, takes his best shot at assassinating Vader.  Seeking justice for Ben Kenobi, Luke son initiates his first duel with Vader.  With C-3PO dismantled by scavengers plundering the Millennium Falcon, Han & Leia must desperately improvise another way out of the destructive chaos.

Han & Leia use a stolen Imperial shuttle to investigate a possible location for the next Rebel base.  Deeming himself a dangerous liability, Luke leaves the Rebellion to take R2-D2 with him to seek possible answers about his past at Ben’s abandoned hut on Tatooine. 

The planet is further teeming with visitors: 1. At the Mos Eisley cantina, a masked predator is hunting for an elusive Han Solo; 2.  Vader personally renews Imperial supply lines with Jabba the Hutt; and 3. At Vader’s behest, Boba Fett ruthlessly seeks out the unknown Rebel pilot who recently destroyed the Death Star.  Again, the cantina is the crime scene for brutal interrogations.

On a storm-plagued world inside the Monsua Nebula, Han & Leia’s forced detour is complicated by someone Han least expects to see. Having already been humiliated by Vader, a blinded Luke now must face Boba Fett alone.  At last, Vader may gain the young Rebel’s identity, who is now becoming his obsession.  These storylines will continue in Volume 2: Showdown on the Smuggler’s Moon.  

REVIEW:

The ‘Force’ is indeed with Marvel Comics in reviving its Star Wars comics franchise.  Impressively, writer Jason Aaron conjures up a storyline that logically extends and explores plot threads stemming from A New Hope.  Virtually everything that fans could want in a near-immediate sequel is present. 

For these first five issues, Aaron proves that he can handle all the necessary details with flair and welcome expertise re: these characters.  His sole overreach is pitting an inexperienced Luke vs. both Vader and Boba Fett too soon.  In that sense, it tarnishes some of the magic witnessing Luke’s subsequent battles in The Empire Strikes Back.

Kudos must also go to the art squad’s visuals.  Case in point: Issue # 5’s cover, for instance, sports perhaps the best-ever comics recreation of Carrie Fisher’s Leia.  By any measuring stick, Marvel easily meets, if not surpasses, all expectations in replicating the classic look of Star Wars for this book.  Of utmost importance this time, the character likenesses are consistently spot-on.  Hence, it’s likely the first time that Harrison Ford, Carrie Fisher, & Mark Hamill actually ‘play’ Han, Leia, and Luke in comics. 

Come to think of it: the only element readers might need to bolster Skywalker Strikes is John Williams’ score playing in the background.  Appropriate for ages 10 and up, even casual fans should be delighted with this initial run of Marvel’s take on Star Wars.          

Note: If you see this book in person, Issue # 5’s cover is also partially reproduced on the back cover.

ADDITIONAL CONTENT:

Each cover is reproduced in a full-page format.  The cover artists are: John Cassady & Laura Martin, with help from Paul Mounts for Issue # 4.

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                    9 Stars

Categories
Books & Novels General Non-Fiction History & Biographies (Books) Westerns

FAMOUS GUNFIGHTERS OF THE WESTERN FRONTIER

Written by W.B. (Bat) Masterson

SUMMARY:

Written by Old West lawman-turned-journalist William Barclay “Bat” Masterson in 1907, these biographical profiles for Human Life Magazine contemplate Luke Short, Ben Thompson, John “Doc” Holliday, Bill Tilghman, and Wyatt Earp.  His articles were subsequently compiled in book form for the first time in 1957.  This 112-page Dover Books reprint was released in 2016.  Half of this book is Masterson’s content. 

Advisory: Quoting Holliday, Masterson repeatedly uses the ‘n-word’ in that particular profile.  In his Earp profile, Masterson casually uses a racial slur dismissing Florentino Cruz (who was killed during Earp’s ‘Vendetta Ride’).

The other half is a black-and-white gallery courtesy of the Noah H. Rose Photograph Collection from the University of Oklahoma Libraries’ Western History Collections.  Including some recreations, photos include:

  • Masterson; Earp; Thompson; the Tom McLaury-Frank McLaury-Billy Clanton coffin display; Tilghman; Holliday; an artistic reproduction of Short; Dodge City (Kansas); John Wesley Hardin; “Wild” Bill Hickok; Jack Harris; Billy Thompson; Billy Breckenridge; King Fisher; Morgan Earp; the building where Jack Harris’ variety theater was located (San Antonio, TX); & a subpoena from a Texas court case against Ben Thompson;
  • James Earp, Virgil Earp; Jim McIntyre; Tombstone (Arizona); Jim Courtright; Shanghai Pierce; Hardin’s revolver that he was carrying at the time of his death; an artistic reproduction of ‘The Dodge City Peace Commission;’ Sheriff John Slaughter; Tilghman & C.F. Celeard; Arizona old-timers; Ed McGivern’s trick shot; Judge Roy Bean’s “court;” Bill Raidler; Shakespeare (New Mexico); and a faded post-mortem image of “Tulsa” Jack Blake’s face.

Advisory: Included are grisly, post-mortem (upper body) close-ups of Hardin and Bill Doolin.    

Historical Note: Both Tilghman and Earp outlived Masterson, who died in 1921.  Tilghman was subsequently killed in the line of duty in 1924.  Earp passed away in early 1929.

REVIEW:

As articulate and witty as Masterson often is, it’s no surprise that Earp, Thompson, and Short receive a wide pass on their historical misdeeds and/or shady behavior.  Case in point: Masterson notes that, yes, Short illegally peddled low-grade whiskey to Native Americans.  Yet, he doesn’t chastise him for swindling his clientele out of their far more valuable buffalo robes.  

Masterson doesn’t even bother criticizing Thompson’s propensity for dangerous bullying antics to later justify ‘self-defense.’ Still, Thompson is his intriguing pick to prevail in hypothetical shootouts with the Old West’s other ‘top guns,’ including Earp, Clay Allison, and “Wild” Bill Hickok.  Staying objective, Masterson contributes welcome insight into the attributes necessary for survival among the best gunmen (beyond getting the drop on one’s adversary).

Note: One name that Masterson doesn’t consider re: how he would have likely matched up against Thompson is the notorious John Wesley Hardin.  As they were supposedly friendly in 1870 Abilene, Kansas, Hardin once declined Thompson’s request to kill Hickok (the town marshal) for him as a personal favor.    

Masterson’s temper rips only when discussing his long-standing dislike of Holliday, in spite of rendering some occasional favors.  For instance, Masterson once finagled a legal ruse, at Earp’s behest, for the fugitive dentist to evade an Arizona murder warrant.  As for his own golden assessment of Earp, Masterson rightly acknowledges that several derogatory stories belittling his long-time friend are spiteful fiction.  Perhaps as a counter-measure, his Earp profile comes off as excessively sanitized, including some inaccurate details describing the O.K. Corral gunfight’s ramifications. 

Re: Bill Tilghman, to some degree, Masterson evidently shared his mutual disdain for Native Americans.  It’s head-shaking that Tilghman’s retaliatory ambush/multiple-homicides of a Native American band for plundering his campsite doesn’t merit even a mild condemnation.  Masterson, in that sense, consistently doesn’t balk at Earp and Tilghman’s lethal use of vigilante tactics, legally justified or not. 

Ultimately, it’s a unique read to explore Masterson’s take on these five Old West legends.  One just has to remember that at least three of them were among Bat’s favorite old cronies. 

The photo section is extensive padding (yes, it’s exactly half this book’s length).  This imagery is worth perusing, though autopsy photos of John Wesley Hardin and Bill Doolin (aside from their grim realism) could have been substituted out for something classier.  Overall, Famous Gunfighters of the Western Frontier isn’t the best go-to source, but it’s an intriguing supplement for more in-depth analysis of Old West gunslinging found elsewhere.       

ADDITIONAL FEATURES:

A table-of-contents is included.  There’s a two-page introduction on the author by an unidentified Time-Life editor.

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                       5½ Stars

Categories
Comic Books & Graphic Novels DC Comics DC's Hardcovers & Trade Paperbacks

GREEN LANTERN (HAL JORDAN): EMERALD DAWN II (DC Comics)

 Written by Keith Giffen & Gerard Jones

Art by M. D. Bright; Romeo Tanghal; Albert De Guzman; & Anthony Tollin 

Compilation Cover Art by Alan Davis; Mark Farmer; & Dave Stewart

Original Cover Art (Issues # 1-6) by Mark Bright

SUMMARY:

Released by DC Comics in 2003, this 144-page paperback compilation reprints 1991’s six-issue sequel mini-series.  Individual issue titles are: 1. “The Powers That Be.”  2. “Balance of Power.”  3.  “Power Play.”  4. “The Will to Power.”   5. “The Price of Power.” and, finally, 6. “The Power and the Glory.”  

Set prior to the epilogue of Emerald Dawn I, Hal Jordan’s guilty plea for a first-time DUI conviction sends him to a maximum-security prison for ninety days.  Short-handed on veteran Green Lanterns, the Guardians of the Universe assign a resentful Sinestro to continue Hal’s training.  Sinestro’s new protégé, therefore, will have to sneak in and out of prison overnight for the foreseeable future. 

Accused for killing his first cellmate, Hal’s in-house legal caseworker is none other than Guy Gardner.  Further complicating matters is that: 1. Hal must trust his subsequent cellmate, Willie, with his emerald secret; and 2. An incarcerated bank robber that Green Lantern recently captured has also deduced fellow inmate Jordan’s masked identity. 

Accompanying Sinestro to his home world of Korugar, Hal is mortified at how Sinestro has condescendingly subjugated his own race into worshipping him under the precept of maintaining ‘order.’ Korugar’s rebellious Katma-Tui, with backing from the alien Khunds, ignites a planetary revolution against Sinestro, and by extension,  a sympathetic Hal.  The young Katma mistakenly deems all Green Lanterns must be blowhard tyrants like Sinestro.  Before being forced to flee together, the two Green Lanterns briefly turn on each other.            

Accompanied by Sinestro, an overdue Hal returns to prison, only to find a vile mass uprising. Guy Gardner is among the hostages, as the bank robber demands Hal’s power ring.  With Sinestro’s help, Hal must contain the murderous riot.  The Guardians send their robotic ‘Fists’ to Earth to apprehend the now-rogue Sinestro.  On planet Oa, Sinestro is on trial by the Guardians for his vast abuses of his Green Lantern oath.  Hal and another pivotal witness may ultimately sway Sinestro’s fate.  The finale presents a different glimpse of Emerald Dawn I’s epilogue.

Note: The Emerald Dawn II mini-series was released after Jordan’s second solo monthly had already begun in 1990. 

REVIEW:

Unlike Emerald Dawn I, this second prequel’s prison-heavy storyline actually lives up to its superb visuals.  Though imagining Hal as an ex-convict before joining the JLA is a dubious stretch, Keith Giffens & Gerard Jones’ inspired storytelling makes up most of the difference.  As Robert Greenberger’s introduction points out, juxtaposing Hal’s conscientious yet uneasy reaction to prison life against his new mentor’s own political evils is an intriguing notion worth exploring. 

In particular, Hal’s initial relationships with Sinestro, Guy Gardner, and, to a lesser degree, Katma-Tui are honed with extra polish.  Along with small yet helpful contributions from Carol Ferris, Kilowog, and Tomar-Re, Hal’s revised backstory (despite the contrived prison angle) scores an impressive ‘flashback’ for the Green Lantern franchise.      

Still, the real MVP of Emerald Dawn II belongs to its art squad.  Their work (i.e. the cover images) are top-caliber for that time, which makes for a complete Green Lantern package.  Regardless of whether or not DC has since retconned this storyline, Emerald Dawn II delivers a remarkably good read.  It serves up a welcome ‘prequel’ for Hal Jordan fans prior to delving into something like 2004’s Green Lantern: Rebirth.       

ADDITIONAL CONTENT:

DC Senior Editor Robert Greenberger presents a single-page introduction.  Inexplicably, artist Mark Bright isn’t credited, full-page reproductions of his covers are included. 

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                        8 Stars

Categories
Comic Books & Graphic Novels DC Comics DC's Hardcovers & Trade Paperbacks

GREEN LANTERN (HAL JORDAN): EMERALD DAWN I (DC Comics)

Written by Jim Owsley (Issue # 1 only); Keith Giffen; & Gerard Jones

Art by M. D. Bright; Romeo Tanghal; Keith Giffen; Albert De Guzman; & Anthony Tollin 

Cover Art by Alan Davis & Mark Farmer

SUMMARY:

Released by DC Comics in 2003, this 144-page paperback compilation reprints the six-issue mini-series from 1989-1990.  The individual issue titles are: 1. “The Sign.”  2. “The Trail.”  3.  “The Ring.”  4. “The Corps.”   5. “The Test.” and, finally, 6. “The Dawn.”   With Green Lantern’s post-Crisis-on-Infinite-Earths popularity waning, DC Comics sought to tweak Hal Jordan’s legendary origin tale. 

Pumped up on hero worship for his daredevil dad, young Hal witnesses test pilot Martin Jordan’s fiery demise at Ferris Air.  Several years later, perpetual screw-up Hal is a newly demoted Ferris Air pilot and recently broken up with supervisor/ex-girlfriend Carol Ferris.  Responsible for a D.U.I. crash injuring three others (including one of his brothers), Hal initially evades taking responsibility for the incident. 

Summoned by a dying Abin Sur, Hal is his chosen replacement as Sector 2814’s new Green Lantern.  Even if a bewildered Hal doesn’t, Sur trusts his power ring’s judgment.

After already killing several Lanterns (Abin Sur, among them), the alien entity known as Legion now vengefully pursues Hal.  Enduring Kilowog’s rushed training regimen on planet Oa, Hal joins the Green Lantern Corps.  Protected by yellow armor, Legion invades Oa to attack the Guardians of the Universe.  The fate of the Corps may rest with this raw human rookie, who is far more unpredictable than any of his fellow Lanterns imagine. Ultimately, Hal must live up to his potential, both as a Green Lantern and as an error-prone mortal back on planet Earth.         

Notes: Emerald Dawn I subsequently propelled Jordan into his second ongoing series in mid-1990.  With Issue # 50, that title was inherited by Kyle Rayner.  The 1991 sequel, Green Lantern: Emerald Dawn II (revisiting the origin of Jordan’s feud with Sinestro), is available in paperback form. 

REVIEW:

Legion’s expendable presence as the villain isn’t Emerald Dawn’s biggest disappointment.  That distinction dubiously belongs to the whiny, self-pitying Hal that readers are stuck with throughout most of this storyline.  Scenes where Hal (likely suffering from a concussion) actually blames a roadside billboard for his D.U.I. crash and then later attacks it as fitful payback are pathetic lows in his newly revised origin. 

Instead of already being honest and fearless, this self-involved, jittery Hal faces some uphill work to attain such obligatory Green Lantern ideals.  Late in the game (Hal vs. Legion – Round 3, no less) is when fans finally see the Green Lantern they expect.  Even then, such euphoria is short-lived, as the lukewarm plotting resumes pitching Hal as a career loser in need of heroic redemption.  Such misguided storytelling diminishes Emerald Dawn as a satisfying read for those preferring Hal as a brash Top Gun-like jet pilot. 

Even so, this project’s interior visuals are excellent for the era; they’re much better than the uninspired cover images.  It’s a shame that the appealing artwork doesn’t support a more entertaining plot.  Emerald Dawn, unfortunately, is a blah experience that misses the point of why Hal’s mythical destiny is so awe-inspiring. Geoff Johns’ energized 2004 Green Lantern: Rebirth (as well as, for instance, his 2008 Secret Origin arc) far, far surpasses Emerald Dawn re: why Hal, in the right creative hands, is DC’s definitive Green Lantern. 

Lifting new backstory material that book-ends Emerald Dawn, Johns also better develops the concept of Hal recklessly following in his father’s doomed footsteps as a hotshot pilot.  In that sense, Emerald Dawn should best be construed as a source from which some superb 21st Century Green Lantern tales would be derived from.      

ADDITIONAL CONTENT:

The original mini-series’ Assistant Editor, Kevin Dooley, presents a single-page introduction.  Full-page reproductions of the covers are included.

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                     5½ Stars

Note: Beyond Johns’ “Secret Origin” story arc, there are two other recommended takes on Hal’s origin tale.  One is Darwyn Cooke’s DC: The New Frontier imagining Green Lantern’s origin amidst the ‘Space Age.’  Both the comics version and its faithful animated adaptation are outstanding.  The other thumbs-up is 2009’s animated Green Lantern: First Flight.  Aside from actor Christopher Meloni’s miscasting as Hal’s voice, this film is terrific.   

Categories
Comic Books & Graphic Novels DC Comics

DETECTIVE COMICS # 854 (2009 DC Comics)

Main Feature & Back-Up Feature Written by Greg Rucka

Main Feature Art by J.H. Williams III; Dave Stewart; & Todd Klein

Back-Up Feature Art by Cully Hamner; Laura Martin; & Jared K. Fletcher

Cover Art by J.H. Williams III

SUMMARY:

Released by DC Comics for August 2009, this issue consists of Batwoman’s“Elegy, Part One: Agitated” and The Question’s “Pipeline, Chapter One-Part One.”  In Gotham City, despite her turbulent romantic life, a weary Kate Kane/Batwoman pushes closer to the identity of the Religion of Crime’s mysterious new boss.  Kate receives a private endorsement from Dick Grayson’s Batman. 

As her equivalent of ‘Alfred,’ Kate’s father, Colonel Jacob Kane, supplies his daughter with an experimental handgun for extra firepower.  Seeking fitting justice after her near-homicide during 52, Batwoman soon faces the bizarre Alice — the ‘queen’ of Gotham’s thirteen crime covens.  

Reminiscent of TV’s The Equalizer, “Pipeline” has Renee Montoya/The Question and her associate, ‘Tot,’ working as freelance crimefighters out of a secluded lighthouse.  Answering a man’s desperate e-mail plea, Renee accepts a case in L.A. to probe the sinister disappearance of his younger sister.  Following a lead to a decrepit neighborhood, The Question soon confirms that the missing Latina female is linked to a human trafficking ring.

Note: Though an image isn’t provided, the variant cover artist is J.G. Jones.

REVIEW:

DC Comics should be commended for depicting lesbian crimefighters (and ex-lovers, no less) co-sharing the Detective Comics flagship title long before this concept became trendy in the industry.

Writing openers for two separate arcs, Greg Rucka is very much on his game.  His take on Kate Kane/Batwoman is inspired: not only is Batwoman a fully realized character, there’s a welcome darker edge of unpredictability to her.  Kate, accordingly, is an ideal amalgam of Barbara Gordon’s adult Batgirl and Helena Bertinellis’s more ruthless Huntress.  Batwoman’s fresh star power, by comparison, makes Dick Grayson’s Batman come off as practically bland. 

Credit must be duly shared with J.H. Williams III, whose dazzling visuals virtually pop off the page.  The glossy, ultra-hip look of “Elegy” should be deemed one of the most impressive painting-like styles ever in comics.

While Renee Montoya’s ongoing back-up series doesn’t scream the instant need for a solo spin-off, her gritty storyline is still effective.  Rucka’s dramatic plotting is structured much like a TV crime show episode just going into the first commercial break.  As with the intriguing Batwoman/Alice stand-off, he induces readers into finding out what happens next — even if it’s just a fight scene.  Also relying on a painting-like style, the back-up art squad’s low-key, almost grungy visuals get the job done well enough. 

Affirming Batwoman and the new Question as major DC players (notably, in Bruce Wayne’s gaping absence), Detective Comics # 854 is excellent reading, plain and simple.  

ADDITIONAL CONTENT:

DC Senior Story Editor Ian Sattler’s “DC Nation” column heralds a creative team (Bill Willingham & Matt Sturges) taking on the JSA series.  

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:                             9 Stars

Categories
Comic Books & Graphic Novels Independent Hardcovers & Trade Paperbacks Independent Publishers (Comic Books & Graphic Novels)

BEST OF JOSIE & THE PUSSYCATS, VOLUME 1 (2001)

Written by (Credits Not Provided)

Art by (Credits Not Provided)

Compilation Cover Art by Rex W. Lindsay & Rosario “Tito” Peña

SUMMARY:

Released by Archie Comics in 2001, this 96-page compilation reprints ten tales, plus some select panels, spanning a quarter-century between 1963 and 1988.  The contents are:

“A Gym Dandy” (She’s Josie # 1 – February 1963): High school kids Josie & Pepper are invited by wealthy classmate Alex Cabot to try out his private home gym.  Josie McCoy, Melody Jones, and Alexander Cabot III are introduced, as are occasional supporting players Pepper and Albert.

One-page sample: The debut of Alexandra Cabot (She’s Josie # 8 – September 1964).

One-page sample: The debut of Alan M. (Josie # 42 – August 1969). 

One-page sample: The origin of Alexandra’s striped hair and Sebastian the Cat’s magical powers (Josie # 43 – September 1969).

“Decisions, Decisions” (Josie & The Pussycats # 45 – December 1969).  Refusing Alexandra’s demands to front their band, Josie & Melody opt to take Alexander’s unexpected suggestion for a third bandmate.  Valerie Smith makes her debut.

“Pussy Footing”  (Josie & The Pussycats # 45 – December 1969).  Playing their high school’s dance that night, the girls’ trademark outfits first appear.

“Quiet on the Set”  (Josie & The Pussycats # 50 – September 1970).  ‘Previewing’ their new animated TV series, the team visits Hanna-Barbera Studios in person.  The story includes comic book versions of TV animation legends Joseph Barbera, William Hanna, Bill Spears, and Joe Ruby.

One-page advertisement for the CBS Josie & The Pussycats animated TV series debut (Josie & The Pussycats # 50 – September 1970).

“Brawn is Beautiful” (Josie & The Pussycats # 53 – February 1971).  To eliminate him as a rival for Josie’s affections, Alex fires Alan M. from the group.  This tactic inevitably backfires.

“Ban the Blonde” (Josie & The Pussycats # 56 – August 1971).  Josie & Valerie are exasperated by a clueless Melody’s sex appeal impacting a lot of their male fans’ jealous girlfriends.  It’s time to take action after the irked girlfriends stage a public protest against the Pussycats.

“The Early Worm Gets the Bird”  (Josie & The Pussycats # 56 – August 1971).  Guest star Archie Andrews joins Alan M. and the girls for some early morning fun at the beach.

“The Ghost of Dark Valley Manor” (Josie & The Pussycats # 57 – September 1971).  Reminiscent of their TV series, this three-part tale has Alex arranges for a Pussycats rehearsal inside a haunted house.

“Up, Up, and Away!” (Josie & The Pussycats # 58 – October 1971).  The girls get literally carried away in a hot air balloon before tangling with an art thief.

One-page sample: A glimpse at the Pussycats’ 1980s MTV punk rock makeover (Archie Giant Series Present Josie & The Pussycats # 540 – August 1984).

“Limo Rock” (Archie Giant Series Present Josie & The Pussycats # 562 – August 1986).  Alex arranges for the girls to film a live music video inside his ultra-deluxe limousine.

“Cat at the Crossroads” (Archie Giant Series Present Josie & The Pussycats # 584 – September 1988).  Worried that she’s under-talented and hurting the band, Josie contemplates quitting and moving on with her life.  For their next gig, Valerie & Melody must reluctantly accept Alexandra as Josie’s replacement.

Note: Archie Comics claims that the inclusion of samples is due to space considerations.

REVIEW:

Considering the slim page count, it’s disappointing that Archie Comics occasionally skimps by resorting to samples vs. the actual stories.  However, this cheerfully undemanding assortment should still please adults in a nostalgic mood.  Young fans may invariably deem the tame humor far too old school for their tastes.  Rest assured that some timeless chuckles will hit their mark with anyone. 

With solid production values, this nice sampler is ideal for collectors interested in perusing Josie & The Pussycats in their vintage form.     

ADDITIONAL CONTENT:

Paul Castiglia provides a two-page introduction contemplating Josie and The Pussycats’ enduring impact on pop culture and girl rock groups inspired by them.  There are also interior front cover (outer space) and interior back cover (skiing) illustrations, but the artists aren’t identified — though it’s probably Lindsay & Peña. 

A table-of-contents identifies each story or sample’s historical source.  Cover reproductions aren’t included.

BRIAN’S ODD MOON RATING:             6½ Stars

Note: Archie Comics has released at least other same-named Best of Josie & The Pussycats paperback; this alternate volume is 400+ pages.